Google Going Hong Kong

March 25, 2010

In Google’s China Play? Search me by Muhammad Cohen, author of Hong Kong On Air, Cohen writes a compelling post about his anger concerning Google’s flight and fight with mainland China’s  government. He says Google has no reasonable objective baiting Beijing and inviting Chinese authorities to crack down on Hong Kong’s freedoms. He says, Google’s longstanding corporate hypocrisy raises questions about its claims of mainland cyber attacks and hacking. I talked about this in Google Recycled (http://wp.me/pN4pY-2r).

Any freedom is a precious gift.  Americans believe they have freedom but what they have isn’t far from what the Chinese have. After all, Americans must pay income tax, sales tax, property tax, wear seat belts while driving or helmets on motor bikes, no smoking in public, no drinking booze or talking on cell phones while driving, and the list goes on. Now Americans have to pay for health insurance, which has given birth to protests across the United States—it’s a shame so many eligible Americans don’t vote.

Many of those freedom restrictions don’t exist in China. What does exist is the fact that Chinese are not allowed to challenge their government in public or in the media—a privilege that has never existed in China ever. However, Hong Kong has this freedom and doesn’t want to lose it.  When Google wanted to do business in China, they agreed to the censorship rules. Now they have broken that agreement.

See “When in Rome, Do as the Romans” http://wp.me/sN4pY-354

 


Sounds like China

March 24, 2010

“But everything I’ve experienced … and heard from journalists there, suggests control over the message has reached obsessive proportions. Even background (anonymous) interviews morph into ‘background with authorization,’ so that a quote from ‘an official’ must pass the review process lest ‘an official,’ should misspeak.”

The West often criticizes China for censoring the Chinese Internet and the media. What they don’t tell us—this is the way it has been for more than a thousand years.

“Chinese media have been tightly regulated since the presses started running some 1,200 years ago …. When Mao Zedong founded People’s Daily as the official mouthpiece of the CCP in 1948, he basically just followed in his predecessor’s imperial footsteps.” Source: Around The Block by Stephani Elizondo Griest

That quote at the top of this post sounded like a  criticism of China, didn’t it?  Wrong.  That quote came from an opinion piece in the New York Times and Roger Cohen was writing about Washington D.C.

You may also want to read American Hypocrisy http://wp.me/pN4pY-6